People use "digital signature" and "electronic signature" as if they mean the same thing. On a PDF they don't. One is a broad legal idea; the other is a specific piece of technology. Knowing which is which helps you understand what a sender is asking for, and why a "signed" PDF sometimes shows a warning.

Electronic signature: a legal category

An electronic signature is defined by what it's for, not how it's made. The US ESIGN Act defines it as "an electronic sound, symbol, or process, attached to or logically associated with a contract or other record and executed or adopted by a person with the intent to sign the record." The EU's eIDAS Regulation says much the same: data in electronic form, attached to or logically associated with other data, "used by the signatory to sign".

That covers a lot:

  • a signature you draw with your finger on a phone;
  • your name typed in a script font;
  • a photo of your signature on paper, placed on the page;
  • clicking "I agree" in a signing service;
  • a digital signature, too, since it's also electronic.

What these laws care about is that you meant to sign. They don't, by themselves, say anything about proving who you are.

Digital signature: a cryptographic technique

A digital signature is one particular way of signing electronically. The PDF standard (ISO 32000-1, section 12.8) describes how it works inside the file: the signing software computes a digest of the document's data, a kind of fingerprint, and stores it in the PDF together with information about the signer. To check the signature, a reader recomputes the digest and compares it. In the standard's words, "Differences in the digest values indicate that modifications have been made since the document was signed."

The digest is protected with the signer's private key and tied to a certificate, so a reader can also show whose certificate made the signature. That gives you two things a drawn signature can't:

  1. Tamper evidence. Change one character after signing and the signature no longer checks out.
  2. A link to an identity, as strong as the certificate behind it.

Side by side

Simple electronic signature Digital signature
What it is A mark that shows you meant to sign A certificate plus a fingerprint of the file, stored in the PDF
Typical form Drawn, typed or photographed signature Often shown as a signature box, but the proof sits in the file's structure
Shows who signed No, anyone can draw a squiggle Yes, as far as the certificate is trusted
Detects later changes No Yes
Needs a certificate No Yes
Good for Everyday forms, permission slips, many contracts Documents where identity and integrity must be checkable

The EU adds three tiers

eIDAS splits electronic signatures into levels:

  • Electronic signature: the broad category above.
  • Advanced electronic signature: Article 26 says it must be uniquely linked to the signatory, capable of identifying them, created with data the signer can use "under his sole control", and linked to the signed data so "any subsequent change in the data is detectable". In practice that means certificate-based technology.
  • Qualified electronic signature: an advanced signature created with a qualified signature creation device and based on a qualified certificate. Article 25 says it "shall have the equivalent legal effect of a handwritten signature" and must be recognized across all member states.

Article 25 also says a plain electronic signature can't be denied legal effect or refused as evidence just because it's electronic or isn't qualified. So a drawn signature still counts as evidence in the EU; it just doesn't get the automatic equal-to-handwritten status.

The US federal rule has no tiers like these. The ESIGN Act says a signature or contract "may not be denied legal effect, validity, or enforceability solely because it is in electronic form". Whether a signature is good enough in a given case is a separate question; is a signed PDF legally binding? goes through it.

Why a digital signature can break

Because a digital signature fingerprints the file, anything that rewrites the file can invalidate it. The PDF standard even lets the first signer, in a "certification" signature, decide what's allowed afterward: no changes at all, only filling in forms and signing, or that plus comments. Anything else invalidates the signature.

That has practical consequences:

  • Signing with a simple tool after someone signed digitally can break their signature. Our Sign PDF tool writes a new copy of the file, so a certificate signature already in it will no longer validate.
  • Removing a password from a signed PDF rewrites the file too. Unlock PDF warns about this for the same reason.
  • Edits belong before signing. Fill in, combine and fix the pages first; sign last.

If a PDF arrives with a digital signature and you also need to sign it, use the software or service the sender asks for. It can add a signature without breaking the earlier one.

Which one does this site's tool make?

The free Sign PDF tool makes simple electronic signatures: your drawn, typed or uploaded signature is placed on the page as an image, and any form fields are filled in. It doesn't create certificate-based digital signatures, and it doesn't prove who signed. For most everyday paperwork that's what people need, and the steps are in how do I electronically sign a PDF?. On an iPhone you can do the same with Markup; see how to sign a PDF on iPhone.

When you send signed documents onward, think about who can see them. A signature image can be copied by anyone who has the file; sharing documents from your iPhone without oversharing has a few habits that help. Big transactions, like a mortgage application, often come with their own signing portal; the applying for a mortgage checklist covers the papers around it.

How to tell what you've been asked for

  • "Sign and return the form" almost always means a simple electronic signature is fine.
  • "Sign with your digital ID" or "certificate" means a digital signature. The sender should say which service or certificate.
  • "Qualified electronic signature" is an EU term for the top tier. You'll need a qualified trust service provider; a drawing won't do.
  • Not sure? Ask the sender. It's a normal question, and the answer saves you from signing twice.

General information, not legal advice. Rules vary by country and by type of document.